18. ___ since graduation from high school, Joe had to find jobs to sustain himself.
(A) Having self-supported
(B) Self-supported
(C) Self-supporting
(D) Being self-supported
統計: A(160), B(45), C(144), D(123), E(0) #2002642
詳解 (共 5 筆)
Self-supporting → 是形容詞
原句:John had been self-supporting since graduation from high school
分詞構句:Having been self-supporting.....
動詞是be V可以省略(請看下圖c.),故得解
附上我問我母語英文的美國朋友,甚至是英文系,他也選錯XD
(朋: I am not wrong though, the test is wrong)
他幫我回覆的解析如下:
The correct answer is (C) Self-supporting.
The phrase "self-supporting" is an adjective that describes Joe's current state of supporting himself since graduation from high school.
Option (A) "Having self-supported" is incorrect because it uses the present perfect tense, which suggests an ongoing action that is not necessarily true in this case.
Option (B) "Self-supported" is grammatically correct, but it is a past tense verb phrase rather than an adjective, which does not fit the context.
Option (D) "Being self-supported" is also incorrect because it uses the present participle form "being" which does not fit the context of the sentence.
是不是應該要是Having been self-supporting 才最正確呢?
應該是Joe has been self-supporting since graduation from high school, so she had to find jobs to sustain herself. 改寫成分詞構句Having been self-supporting since… , Joe had to…
是這樣吧?